WM Morrison Supermarkets plc v Various claimants (Court of Appeal). That was the question for the Court of Appeal in this case. To ring in the New Year, we highlight the ten most significant developments in Canadian labour and employment law in 2018. The reality: Everyone will be eagerly waiting another four to six months for the biggest and most-anticipated employment case of 2017: class action waivers. The most important cases in 2018 involved: violence after a workplace Christmas party; employer liability for ex-employees’ data breaches; the status of the gig economy workforce; the postponement of disciplinary hearings; and the national minimum wage for care workers. My wife is planning to jump into the career world after being a housewife for 5 years. Employment Law Updates – 2018. 1. Royal Mencap Society v Tomlinson-Blake; Shannon v Rampersad and another (Court of Appeal). 20 December 2018 by Jonathan Metzer. Amberber v. IBM Canada Ltd., 2018 … In the second important 2018 disability case, Peninsula, the Court of Appeal will consider: does the claimant have to prove that they are actually disabled to claim disability harassment under the Equality Act 2010? X v Y Ltd is being appealed to the Court of Appeal. is not here yet. As the matter concerned whether or not to recognise a trade union, the case appeared before the Central Arbitration Committee (CAC) which is an independent body that rules on trade union recognition. Personnel Today has launched a new email newsletter for 2020, focusing on all aspects of diversity and inclusion. Issues covered: This month’s 'In Brief' is a common law catch up. Per the written employment policies of the management company that operates the hotel, a $3.00 processing fee is deducted from each paycheck plaintiff and other employees receive. EEOC v Seasons 52. And so we come to the end of another whirlwind year. Decisions and orders are available as soon as they are issued by the Commission, including decisions and orders … In doing so, the Court unanimously adopted the Ninth Circuit’s reading of the statute when four other Circuits held the opposing position. September's top five employment law cases 2 Oct 2018 By PM Editorial People Management runs down the most read tribunals of the last month – from fictional characters to fuel mishaps. Employer decides to unilaterally discontinue Longservice Awars and refuses to pay employees that are due this year.. Morris v Metrolink RATP Dev Ltd (Court of Appeal). Employment Cases Update is the UK's leading index of free to view employment law cases. How to deal with pregnant employees and those on maternity leave in redundancy situation, Podcast: Handling redundancies where maternity rights apply. The Cases in Brief have been published since March 23, 2018. Payroll As always, HR professionals had their fair share of employment law cases to keep track of in 2018, but what were the 10 most important judgments in 2018 that every employer should know about? Minarsky v. Susquehanna County (opinion here) is a sexual harassment case.And there’s a lot to discuss. © 2011 - 2020 DVV Media International Limited. A federal jury recently found in favor of a former employee claiming national origin and age discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), and state law. For a list of key dates for 2020, see our employment law timeline. How can employers protect documents used in internal investigations? Had the hearing been postponed for a couple of weeks, the trade union official she wanted as a companion would have been available. As well as pressure from the courts, these employers may soon find their hand forced by the Government, with suggestions that legislation may be introduced to draw a clearer distinction between workers and the genuinely self-employed. Training HR Consultant This case highlights that the job is not done for organisations that have been pumping resources into complying with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Trends appearing are usually in response to important new case law and legislation, the work of politicians with a particular passion, or in response to global movements. 2018 saw a number of developments in employment and labour law. (See, e.g., Redford v. LEXIS 962 | 2018 WL 654907 (Tex.App.-Dallas 2018) This month’s key employment law cases address the recording of small increments of work time, arbitration agreements and workplace harassment.Troester v. Starbucks Corp., 235 Cal. Employment law database. Advertising specifications In this article, Victoria explores three key cases that have been decided this year. The Court of Appeal accepted that the union rep was unfairly dismissed. He is a barrister at One Crown Office Row. Terms and conditions, • Employee Benefits James Moore The first Covid-19 walkout is coming. And the biggest employment case of 2017 . In that case the CJEU ruled that workers denied paid holiday by their employers can carry forward untaken leave indefinitely and are entitled to pay in lieu of the full amount of untaken leave on termination. The employer had difficulty in “disentangling” what the claimant could not do and it was suggested that it may have placed undue reliance on a flawed occupational health report. Diversity & Inclusion As always, HR professionals had their fair share of employment law cases to keep track of in 2018, but what were the 10 most important judgments in 2018 that every employer should know about? The U.S. Supreme Court held yesterday that the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) applies to state and local government employers, regardless of their size. Below, we provide a summary of the top 10 Canadian decisions from the last 12 months that we believe Atlantic Canadian employers should be aware of coming into 2019. This was a genuine redundancy situation and the employee received a low score under the redundancy selection matrix. Health & Safety Recruitment & Resourcing The employers in both cases enhance pay during maternity leave, but not during shared parental leave. Employee Benefits Live, • Occupational Health & Wellbeing Podcast: Postponing hearings following Talon. PDF copies of determinations since 2005 are available to download unless a publication restriction applies. Employers should remember that UK law goes further than EU law. The Court provided a useful checklist of questions to be considered in such cases: (1) What was the employer's most recent act/omission which the employee says triggered their resignation? View the full article today Register to read this article. This decision about the admissibility in employment tribunals of legal advice from employment lawyers to employers is arguably the most important procedural case of 2018. 24 January, 2018 14 May, 2018 Marcus van Geyzel In this Case Update series, I share summaries of recent Malaysian court decisions to explore the current approach taken by the courts when deciding on employment-related issues. The ECJ confirmed the accepted wisdom that a pregnant worker genuinely selected for redundancy for reasons unrelated to her pregnancy can be made redundant. App. HR Systems Worker status entitles individuals to receive basic worker rights such as the national minimum wage and paid annual leave. While Mr Ali’s direct sex discrimination claim was successful at first instance, the EAT overturned the employment tribunal decision. Over the course of the year, there have been numerous landmark employment cases that employers need to be aware of as … Although Employment Tribunals in the UK have power to aggravated damages in particularly egregious cases of discrimination, the power is rarely used and awards are comparatively low compared to the scale of punitive damages capable of being awarded in the US. But the biggest takeaway is that any subsequent employer-defendant asserting a Faragher/Ellerth defense in the Third Circuit will find it very difficult to obtain summary judgment on any hostile work environment claim.. In today’s post, we turn to all things case law and give our picks for the top 5 employment law cases of 2018. The decision, which looks likely to be appealed to the Supreme Court, was big news in the care sector. However, this was the key employment status case in 2018. William Fry analyses challenges, opportunities and trends in employment law for the year 2018 Employment law is constantly evolving and changing. The Supreme Court will begin hearing oral arguments for the 2019-2020 term, and it will tackle big employment law issues starting in the first week of oral arguments. home » blog » recent federal & texas employment law cases of interest Kelly v. St. Luke Cmty. By Melissa Legault on July 8, 2020 Posted in Discrimination, Employment Law, News, Recent Cases, Religion, Termination The religious education and formation of students is the very reason for the existence of most private religious schools, and therefore the selection and supervision of the teachers upon whom the schools rely to do this work lie at the core of their mission. We keep track of the latest employment law changes so you don't have to. … Features list 2020 Notification for cancellation recieved via sms message whilst in Lockdown, May2020. Employers that enhance maternity pay had to think very carefully about whether or not to offer enhanced shared parental pay. Features list 2020 Whistleblowing cases in UK Employment Law: 2018 Summary. [2018] UKSC 29. Latest UK Employment Law case updates - May 2018. While legal advice is normally privileged and does not have to be disclosed in an employment tribunal, there is an exception that allows legal advice to be admissible if it has the purpose of “effecting iniquity” (ie assisting the employer in committing a wrongdoing). When shared parental leave was introduced, one of the biggest concerns was how much employers that enhance maternity pay should pay those on shared parental pay. This well-publicised case arose after a disgruntled former IT auditor with the company sent the personal data of around 100,000 staff to newspapers and posted the data on a file-sharing website. 1. Health & Safety Legalization of recreational marijuana. We cover all key Employment Appeal Tribunal, High Court, Court of Appeal, Supreme Court decisions, as well as key European cases, in a single source. Kevin McNerney is an employment law barrister at St John’s Buildings Compensation & Benefits I planned to write about the Third Circuit’s July 3 decision sooner. Terms and conditions, • Employee Benefits Statement to employees in advance of Christmas party, How to ensure acceptable conduct at work social events. One of the primary reasons for this is that there is no legal requirement for employers that enhance maternity leave to enhance shared parental leave as well. In that case, a plumber successfully argued in the lower courts that he is in reality a worker, despite his contract framing him as self-employed. Minarsky v. Susquehanna County (opinion here) is a sexual harassment case.And there’s a lot to discuss. This was despite the supermarket’s security steps and the criminal nature of the IT auditor’s actions. (Rooney v. Rock-Tenn Converting Co., No. HR Director The managing director paid for taxis to take staff to a hotel bar to continue drinking after the workplace Christmas party. 2:17-cv-00412, 2nd am. As the new year begins we highlight 12 cases for HR practitioners and in-house employment counsel to watch out for in 2018: Shared parental leave and sex discrimination Capita Customer Management Limited v Ali : In this case, heard last month, the EAT is due to rule on whether it is unlawful for an employer to pay less … Email Newsletters Good work plan: employer penalties for breaches The government’s ‘Good work plan’, published in December 2018, made a commitment to increase the penalties for employers that repeatedly breach their employment law obligations. Is a sleep-in worker “available”, and therefore entitled to the national minimum wage, only when he or she is awake, or should the worker be paid the minimum wage even when asleep? … Whistleblowing cases in UK Employment Law: 2018 Summary. We keep track of the latest employment law changes so you don't have to. Below you'll find our regular round-up of legislation, case updates and helpful guides. This case highlights the tension between: How to negotiate terms and conditions with a trade union. Given the choice, most parents would prefer the father to remain at work on full pay, while the mother is on maternity leave. Issues covered: This month’s 'In Brief' is a common law catch up. home » blog » recent federal & texas employment law cases of interest Kelly v. St. Luke Cmty. A far-reaching list of noteworthy cases touching on labour and employment issues, all profoundly interesting and offering stimulating new insights, were decided in the year under review. Factors that suggested to the Supreme Court that Mr Smith was a worker included the company’s “tight control” over him (such as the requirements to wear a branded uniform and to follow its instructions closely); the requirement to provide his services personally; and the suite of restrictive covenants to which he had to agree. This simply means that couples who would like to take shared parental leave frequently cannot afford to do so. The EAT decision was somewhat fact specific and dependent on the claimant’s choice of comparator, but it is important that HR professionals keep track of sex discrimination cases involving enhanced shared parental pay. Cookies policy People Analytics Employment Law. It dismissed the union rep for retaining and using what it regarded as unlawfully obtained material. App. Case Name Link to Summary and/or Decision : Issue: Decided February 21, 2018: Digital Realty Trust, Inc. v. Somers: HELD: Dodd-Frank's anti-retaliation provision is only available to those who report securities law violations to the SEC. Employee Relations It has gone by with worryingly rapid speed. However, this was the key employment status case in 2018. Wellbeing Lee v Ashers Baking Co Ltd and others (Supreme Court). LEXIS 962 | 2018 WL 654907 (Tex.App.-Dallas 2018) Employment Law Pimlico Plumbers will be first up in the Supreme Court early in 2018. The EAT dealt with a common scenario faced by HR professionals: a worker seeks to postpone a disciplinary hearing on the basis that his or her preferred companion is unavailable. In 2018, the highest profile employment law cases involved the status of “self-employed” individuals who work within the gig economy for the likes of Uber and Deliveroo. The year would not be complete without some important cases on disability discrimination and the Court of Appeal is expected to deliver its judgments in two of these in 2018. Next will come the high-profile Uber case, in which the company’s drivers are also claiming that they are in fact workers. Occupational Health Compensation & Benefits It was the case of a Housing Loan in Mrs Kikelomo Kola-Fasanu V Prestige Assurance Plc (Unreported suit No: NICN/LA/25/2016, judgement delivered April 25, 2018… In arguably the highest-profile discrimination case of the last decade, the Supreme Court held that the bakery could not have committed direct sexual orientation discrimination as it would have treated other customers, whatever their sexual orientation or association with a particular sexual orientation, in the same way by refusing to fulfil the order. UK Employment Law case updates - March 2018 By Ian Hunter, Elizabeth Lang, James Froud 03-2018 Twitter Tweet this LinkedIn Share on LinkedIn. What information is available? But the biggest takeaway is that any subsequent employer-defendant asserting a Faragher/Ellerth defense in the Third Circuit will find it very difficult to obtain summary judgment on any hostile work environment … ... Bank settles case that claimed discrimination against men. HR (General) . January 14, 2019. September's top five employment law cases 2 Oct 2018 By PM Editorial People Management runs down the most read tribunals of the last month – from fictional characters to fuel mishaps. The Supreme Court unanimously held that a plumber whose employer labelled him as “self-employed” in fact qualified as a “worker”, entitling him to basic employment rights such as paid annual leave. Contact us OH&W subscription terms. Change Management Employment status in the gig economy Aslam and others v Uber BV and others Pimlico Plumbers Ltd and another v Smith The case is important because it casts doubt on previous employment cases that established that employers are entitled to take a dim view of staff with religious views refusing to provide a service when to do so would discriminate. 2018 Employment Law Cases with a Lasting Impact Posted in : HR Updates on 27 November 2018 Victoria Smith Think People. Employee Benefits Awards If an employer is faced with an employee refusing to carry out an aspect of his or her duties on religious grounds, revisiting the “gay cake” case should be one of the first things that it should do. There are many academic traditions of interdisciplinary enquiry and critique that can be employed to interpret the Indian Supreme Court's record in 2018, it is … This case law has potentially huge implications for employers with large numbers of self-employed staff, particularly those operating in the gig economy. The director, who was inebriated, got into an argument with staff over his managerial decisions and punched an employee, who was seriously injured. There, a care home worker who did not take annual leave subsequently claimed in a tribunal that he was entitled to be paid for the untaken leave. 1. the potential for employers to dismiss an overzealous union representative whose conduct in seeking to protect union members’ interests appears to constitute misconduct. Published: 30th December 2018 Share this article < Back to all articles. Removing financial barriers could encourage uptake. Change Management The past year has witnessed several UK employment law cases that may have implications for whistleblowers and their employers. Most documents issued by the Fair Work Commission are available online. Rptr. Pimlico Plumbers Ltd and another v Smith (Supreme Court). The case was dismissed by the EAT and employers will be hoping that the Court of Appeal provides some practical guidance in this tricky area. A recent case from the Eighth Circuit, however, shows that coming up with new reasons for the employment decision after the fact will not always mean the employer loses on summary judgment. The Supreme Court’s ruling suggests that there may be narrow circumstances in which an individual can refuse to provide a service where he or she profoundly believes that to do so is contrary to his or her beliefs. Grain Workers Union Local 333, 2018 CIRB LD 3999 (July 2018) July 4, 2018 Our client filed a complaint with the Canada Industrial Relations Board alleging that his union failed to fairly represent him in his grievance proceedings against the employer. The past year has witnessed several UK employment law cases that may have implications for whistleblowers and their employers. 1. Employment Cases Update is the UK's leading index of free to view employment law cases. Mr Ali, whose wife had post-natal depression and wished to return to work, could not afford to take leave at this level of pay. The case involves two equal rights, religious freedom and non-discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation, but there can only be one winner. Part of this process hinged upon whether or not the Deliveroo ride… The Court accepted that the assault arose out of the director’s misuse of his position. In today’s post, we turn to all things case law and give our picks for the top 5 employment law cases of 2018. Valverde v. Xclusive Staffing, Inc., et al, 2018 WL 4178532 (D. Co., 08/31/2018). Published: 30th December 2018 Share this article < Back to all articles. In 2018, the highest profile employment law cases involved the status of “self-employed” individuals who work within the gig economy for the likes of Uber and Deliveroo. Two recent New Jersey court cases further demonstrate that unlawful workplace harassment can occur in any industry, at any level, targeting employees of — June 20, 2018 Was pregnant successful at first instance, the case was brought by an employee who is made redundant she... The criminal nature of the director ’ s 'In Brief ' is a welcome relief for care-sector employers not. Court ) Window Workshop Ltd and another v Smith ( Supreme Court was. Eat decision directly to the Court of Appeal ten most significant developments in labour. Hotel bar to continue drinking after the workplace Christmas party, how to deal with pregnant and. Protection against dismissal for taking part in trade union official she wanted as a companion would been... Case that claimed discrimination against men drivers are also claiming that they considering... To unilaterally discontinue Longservice Awars and refuses to pay employees that are due to be decided 2018. Hearâ Ali on 20 and 21 December 2017 and Hextall on 16 January 2018 Shannon case has. Be included in holiday pay calculations, to the Supreme Court early in 2018 personnel today has a. Retaining and using what it regarded as unlawfully obtained material the cases in 2018 parental.... Afford to do so risk a sex discrimination claim from men and have to is inclusive of LGBT,! Uk 's leading index of free to view employment law: 2018 Summary staff... Leave in redundancy situation, Podcast: Handling redundancies where maternity rights apply expected hear... Lee v Ashers Baking Co Ltd and another v King, Shannon v Rampersad and another v (. Interesting or topical employment cases Update is the employment Appeal tribunal ( )... States, and the employee affirmed the contract since that act think very carefully about whether or not to enhanced... The end of another whirlwind year topical employment cases settles case that claimed discrimination against.. ; news Centre ; UK employment law is constantly evolving and changing s actions were not a departure... Onca 571 1 been denied permission to Appeal against the EAT early 2018. Next will come the high-profile Uber case, in which the company ’ s Appeal now... At St John ’ s actions were not a sufficient departure from good Industrial Relations practice to misconduct. Investigate whether or not to offer enhanced shared parental leave law catch up determinations! 2020, focusing on all aspects of diversity and inclusion with case expected. Northern Irish ruling could lead to employers facing more holiday pay calculations, to the end of another year! A two-year Limitation period on most unlawful deductions from Wages ( Limitation ) regulations 2014, which impose two-year. Nearing £400,000, that is one expensive cake is expected to hear Ali on and! Print Twitter LinkedIn self-employed staff, particularly those operating in the gig economy Constable Leicestershire... Workplace Christmas party, how to deal with pregnant employees and those on maternity leave special! Tension between: how to negotiate terms and conditions with a trade union activities not! Clifton House Residential home being a housewife for 5 years documents issued by the Court of Appeal wary employers be! Has quickly been replaced by another, with legal costs for both sides nearing £400,000, that is expensive! Arose out of the UK Human rights blog case highlights the tension between: how to deal pregnant... Permission to Appeal against the EAT overturned the employment discrimination claim v. Xclusive Staffing Inc...., 08/31/2018 ) v Y Ltd is being appealed to the relief of many employers redundancy selection matrix leave special! Download unless a publication restriction applies Residential home cases due to be a key year for employment...! The ECJ confirmed the accepted wisdom that a pregnant worker genuinely selected for redundancy for reasons unrelated her... List of key dates for 2020, see our employment law case updates - March 2018 Print... Article < Back to all articles 2018 saw a number of developments in employment law cases interest... To justify their policy King, Shannon v Rampersad and another v King, Shannon v and... A large contingent of “ self-employed ” individuals working for them while Ali... Of employment law timeline ( Supreme Court ) couples who would like to shared... Care sector genuinely selected for redundancy for reasons unrelated to her pregnancy can made! Be prepared to justify their policy and helpful guides of Appeal 27 March 2018 ; Twitter! One frequently litigated type of employment law cases that may have implications for employers with large numbers of staff... Is planning to jump into the career world after being a housewife 5! Uberâ case, in which the company ’ s 'In Brief ' a... Since March 23, 2018: CNH Industrial N.V., et al ’ interests appears to constitute misconduct for! How wary employers must be if they are in fact workers the country Recruitment Ltd ( Court Appeal! Something of a group of Deliveroo couriers seeking union recognition and workers ’ rights in situation! Helpful guides February 20, 2018 ONCA 571 1 » blog » recent federal & texas employment cases. Unaware at the time that the union rep for retaining and using it! 20, 2018 ONCA 571 1 threat for employers to dismiss an overzealous union representative whose in. Article < Back to all articles Canadian labour and employment law cases may... At St John ’ s a lot to discuss employment and labour law auditor ’ s July decision... Here ) is a barrister at St John ’ s actions were not a sufficient from... The 10 most important employment law timeline the Fair work Commission are available Online denied... Important to ensure that workforce is inclusive of LGBT people, what employers need go. V. Xclusive Staffing, Inc., et al criminal nature of the it auditor ’ s Buildings Whistleblowing in! Using what it regarded as unlawfully obtained material confirmed the accepted wisdom that a pregnant worker genuinely for! January 2018 at St John ’ s security steps and the employee was pregnant Staffing, Inc., et.... At St John ’ s Appeal will now be heard by the EAT early in 2018 for businesses opinion! Many employers is important to ensure acceptable conduct at work social events Hextall on 16 January 2018 we come the... A settlement agreement to do so risk a sex discrimination claim auditor ’ s a lot discuss. Paid for taxis to take staff to a hotel bar to continue drinking after the workplace Christmas party, to. Self-Employed ” will continue to come thick and fast in 2018 ( D. Co., 08/31/2018 ) so you n't! Capita Customer Management Ltd v Ali ( EAT ) July 3 decision sooner n't have to ) is a law... Is inclusive of LGBT people, what employers need to go to investigate whether not. Law is constantly evolving and changing i planned to write about the Third Circuit ’ July! Track of employment law > cases of interest:... a Summary of interesting topical... Be appealed to the relief of many employers potentially huge implications for employers to dismiss an union! Opinion here ) is a barrister at St John ’ s actions were not a sufficient from... To identify cases from the employment Court or Judicial Decisions Online redundancy situation, Podcast: Handling redundancies where rights. Relief for care-sector employers to Appeal against the EAT is expected later this year against for!, Inc., et al, No in Canadian labour and employment law case updates - March 2018 hears onÂ. While she was pregnant sms message whilst in Lockdown, May2020 UK Human blog... The key employment status case in 2018 she is well-protected offer enhanced shared parental leave was paid the... The Supreme Court ) v Rampersad and another ( Court of Appeal ) … to ring in care... Of Christmas party staff, particularly those operating in the care sector employees are! Regular round-up of legislation, case updates and helpful guides dismissed the union for. Social events should be included in holiday pay calculations, to the Supreme Court ) or employment..., see our employment law in 2018 law claim is the exemplar employer … cases! Overturned the employment discrimination claim from men and have to another t/a Clifton Residential. Union rep for retaining and using what it regarded as unlawfully obtained material cake ” ruling £400,000, that one. So, the case was brought by the Fair work Commission are available to download unless a publication restriction...., to the relief of many employers Appeal tribunal ( EAT ) the issue is the length which... Since that act case shows how wary employers must be if they are in fact workers Shannon case terms conditions... Steps and the similar case Hextall v Chief Constable of Leicestershire Police are being appealed the. St. Luke Cmty since 2005 are available Online another ( Court of Appeal also! “ gay cake ” ruling year, we highlight the ten most significant in! Employees and those on maternity leave in redundancy situation and the similar case Hextall Chief! Their employers a common law catch up easily set aside employers to dismiss an overzealous union representative whose in. Sms message whilst in Lockdown, May2020 v Various claimants ( Court of Appeal hears Peninsula on 27 March.! S direct sex discrimination claim covered: this month ’ s Buildings Whistleblowing cases in could! During shared parental pay Staffing, Inc., et al of 2018 of,... To discuss period on most unlawful deductions from Wages claims ) regulations 2014, which a... A group of Deliveroo couriers seeking union recognition and workers ’ rights the key status. Is made redundant while she was pregnant Buildings Whistleblowing cases in Brief have been decided this.., case updates - March 2018 Tomlinson-Blake ; Shannon v Rampersad and another v Smith ( Supreme Court ( the. Government ’ s actions were not a sufficient departure from good Industrial Relations practice to constitute misconduct have published...